{
  "model": "claude-haiku-5-5",
  "category": "edit",
  "scenarios": [
    {
      "id": "b1-inventory-fix",
      "status": "pass",
      "product_defects": [],
      "task_outcome": "Fixed inventory/report defects and added CSV export; independently ran npm test: 11/11 pass; original tests unchanged and all three Changes entries preserve correct baselines and latest bytes.",
      "notes": "Initial failing tests were shell-piped by the model; subsequent fixes and rerun succeeded. Evidence: review-audit.json, review-npm-test.log. Common audit: exit 0, 1 completed turn(s), saved tool pairs 14/14, empty driver.err/errors/leftovers, 30 tools with complete six-skill catalog, no Skill calls or DSH/team-memory effects. Cost $0.005533685 and cache ratio recompute exactly; assigned port empty after review."
    },
    {
      "id": "b2-inventory-approvals",
      "status": "pass",
      "product_defects": [],
      "task_outcome": "Fixed inventory/report defects; independently ran npm test: 5/5 pass; five unique approvals preceded three Bash and two FileEdit calls; seeded test file unchanged.",
      "notes": "Driver answers each approval using its requestId (driver10b.ts:66); no duplicate identical approval or hang. Both Changes baselines and versions match. Evidence: review-specific.json, review-audit.json, review-npm-test.log. Common audit: exit 0, 1 completed turn(s), saved tool pairs 8/8, empty driver.err/errors/leftovers, 30 tools with complete six-skill catalog, no Skill calls or DSH/team-memory effects. Cost $0.003316385 and cache ratio recompute exactly; assigned port empty after review."
    },
    {
      "id": "b3-inventory-deny",
      "status": "pass",
      "product_defects": [],
      "task_outcome": "One Bash approval was denied; no tool executed and all project bytes remain seeded; both turns completed; reviewer tests retain the five expected seeded failures.",
      "notes": "Saved state remains denied, result says \"You declined this Bash call. Nothing was run.\", and second response accurately explains the denial in two sentences. Saved pairing is 1/1; no protocol tool-use for a denied call is intentional. Evidence: review-specific.json, review-audit.json, review-unchanged-tests.log. Common audit: exit 0, 2 completed turn(s), saved tool pairs 1/1, empty driver.err/errors/leftovers, 30 tools with complete six-skill catalog, no Skill calls or DSH/team-memory effects. Cost $0.000964410 and cache ratio recompute exactly; assigned port empty after review."
    },
    {
      "id": "b4-js-to-ts",
      "status": "pass",
      "product_defects": [],
      "task_outcome": "Renamed both JS files to strictly typed TS, added empty-array errors and tests; independent TypeScript noEmit check and npm test pass (5/5).",
      "notes": "Both old JS files are correctly marked deleted with original baselines; new TS files have absent baselines and ordered versions. All eight outputs match final bytes. Existing dependencies used without installs/upgrades. Evidence: review-typecheck.log, review-npm-test.log, review-audit.json. Common audit: exit 0, 1 completed turn(s), saved tool pairs 15/15, empty driver.err/errors/leftovers, 30 tools with complete six-skill catalog, no Skill calls or DSH/team-memory effects. Cost $0.006139840 and cache ratio recompute exactly; assigned port empty after review."
    },
    {
      "id": "b5-python-lib",
      "status": "pass",
      "product_defects": [],
      "task_outcome": "Corrected quantity totals and percentage/bounds logic; independent unittest discovery passes 3/3; test_cart.py unchanged and original cart.py baseline verified.",
      "notes": "Model added an empty tests/__init__.py to make requested discovery work; no test assertions changed. Both outputs have correct baselines. Evidence: review-unittest.log, review-audit.json. Common audit: exit 0, 1 completed turn(s), saved tool pairs 9/9, empty driver.err/errors/leftovers, 30 tools with complete six-skill catalog, no Skill calls or DSH/team-memory effects. Cost $0.002705840 and cache ratio recompute exactly; assigned port empty after review."
    },
    {
      "id": "b6-rename-across-files",
      "status": "pass",
      "product_defects": [],
      "task_outcome": "Renamed definition and all 15 call sites; zero old-name references in src; independently imported and checked all 16 modules successfully.",
      "notes": "All 16 edited sources plus the verification script appear once in Changes with correct baselines. One executed Bash ended 1 because grep found no CR characters; correctly saved as failed, then successful work continued. Evidence: review-import-check.log, review-specific.json, review-audit.json. Common audit: exit 0, 1 completed turn(s), saved tool pairs 6/6, empty driver.err/errors/leftovers, 30 tools with complete six-skill catalog, no Skill calls or DSH/team-memory effects. Cost $0.003230535 and cache ratio recompute exactly; assigned port empty after review."
    },
    {
      "id": "b7-notebook",
      "status": "pass",
      "product_defects": [],
      "task_outcome": "Two NotebookEdit calls produced valid nbformat 4 JSON with four cells; original cell sources preserved; independently executed cells and verified mean 7.25 and max 13.",
      "notes": "Existing notebook has the exact seeded baseline and two valid ordered versions; generated cell IDs are unique. Evidence: review-cell-check.log, review-audit.json. Common audit: exit 0, 1 completed turn(s), saved tool pairs 7/7, empty driver.err/errors/leftovers, 30 tools with complete six-skill catalog, no Skill calls or DSH/team-memory effects. Cost $0.002990595 and cache ratio recompute exactly; assigned port empty after review."
    },
    {
      "id": "b8-large-file-edit",
      "status": "pass",
      "product_defects": [],
      "task_outcome": "Verified exactly the requested three multiply substitutions, fn42 deletion and JSDoc addition; all 2,999 function lines match expected bytes and the behavior script passes 11 checks.",
      "notes": "Original 3,000-line baseline and both edit versions verified. One Bash ran and returned 1 on no CR grep matches, correctly marked failed; the later edits and checks succeeded. Evidence: review-behavior-check.log, review-specific.json, review-audit.json. Common audit: exit 0, 1 completed turn(s), saved tool pairs 8/8, empty driver.err/errors/leftovers, 30 tools with complete six-skill catalog, no Skill calls or DSH/team-memory effects. Cost $0.005118990 and cache ratio recompute exactly; assigned port empty after review."
    },
    {
      "id": "j3-refactor-legacy",
      "status": "pass",
      "product_defects": [],
      "task_outcome": "Split the three largest seed components (475/348/319 lines) into 27 changed/new files; all baselines/versions correct; no original normalized source lines lost; independent relative-import bundles pass.",
      "notes": "Exact requested bundling fails for both seed and result because fixture npm packages are missing; packages-external bundling succeeds for both. No runtime UI equivalence claim or project test suite is available. All 29 engine tool calls completed: shell subcommand build/typecheck errors were masked by model-written shell endings, so zero tool failures/refusals and no failure guard trigger were correct. Inspected guard limits (repeat 3, total 6, success reset). Context7 provided adjacent esbuild 0.28.1 docs; installed 0.28.2 help and actual behavior checked without upgrades. Evidence: review-specific.json, review-bundle-relative-imports.log, review-seed-bundle-relative-imports.log, review-bundle-exact.log, review-seed-bundle-exact.log. Common audit: exit 0, 1 completed turn(s), saved tool pairs 29/29, empty driver.err/errors/leftovers, 30 tools with complete six-skill catalog, no Skill calls or DSH/team-memory effects. Cost $0.097116935 and cache ratio recompute exactly; assigned port empty after review."
    },
    {
      "id": "j4-docs-from-code",
      "status": "pass",
      "product_defects": [],
      "task_outcome": "Generated documentation for all 11 TypeScript modules plus README; exported function/class names and signatures checked, all 11 README links resolve, and source files remain unchanged.",
      "notes": "All 12 documentation outputs have absent baselines and valid final snapshots. Old [removed for publication: GPCI's details]/64-call descriptions refer to this historical fixture source, not current snapshot10t behavior. Evidence: review-specific.json, review-source-signatures.json, review-audit.json. Common audit: exit 0, 1 completed turn(s), saved tool pairs 31/31, empty driver.err/errors/leftovers, 30 tools with complete six-skill catalog, no Skill calls or DSH/team-memory effects. Cost $0.020205375 and cache ratio recompute exactly; assigned port empty after review."
    },
    {
      "id": "j5-git-project",
      "status": "pass",
      "product_defects": [],
      "task_outcome": "Fixed tests without changing them; independent npm test passes 5/5; commit c1fbf62 contains only two source fixes, working tree is clean, and git fsck passes.",
      "notes": "Commit message: Fix inventory accounting, stock checks, and value formatting. Both Changes baselines match the initial commit; latest versions match committed HEAD bytes. Evidence: review-git-history.log, review-git-status.log, review-git-integrity.log, review-specific.json, review-npm-test.log. Common audit: exit 0, 1 completed turn(s), saved tool pairs 12/12, empty driver.err/errors/leftovers, 30 tools with complete six-skill catalog, no Skill calls or DSH/team-memory effects. Cost $0.003874760 and cache ratio recompute exactly; assigned port empty after review."
    }
  ]
}
